Tax burden falls on poor

Opinion

November 4, 2009

Anonymous The Hendricks County Flyer Wed Nov 04, 2009, 03:58 PM EST

To the Editor:

There has been much discussion about executive compensation, especially for those companies that received taxpayer funding. There has also been a lot of discussion regarding paying for universal health care without increasing taxes or the deficit (recall the Obama campaign wanting to raise taxes on those earning more that $250,000 per year?).

At the instigation of a noted Hendricks County officeholder, I looked into the historic tax rates going back to 1913, and the results were thought-provoking. Initially, the lowest tax bracket was taxed at 1 percent, and the highest at 7 percent. During World War I, taxes were increased to 2 percent, then 6 percent for the lowest bracket, and to 67 percent and 77 percent for the highest bracket.

It is interesting that following the first world war, taxes were reduced to as low as 0.375 percent for the lowest bracket and 24 percent for the highest bracket in 1929, then increased slightly during the Depression to 1.125 percent and 25 percent respectively in 1930-31. During the peak part of the Depression, taxes were increased to 4 percent and 63 percent respectively, then leading into WW II to 10 percent and 81 percent. In 1944-45 they were at their highest, 23 percent and 94 percent. After the second world war, rates decreased slightly, and then increased to 22.2 percent and 92 percent during the Korean conflict.

There were gradual decreases in the following years to 14 percent and 70 percent respectively from 1971-81, and then in 1982 the lowest rate decreased to 12 percent, while the top bracket decreased to 50 percent. If your adjusted gross income was $20,000 in 1981, your income tax decreased $200, but if your AGI was $500,000, your tax decreased $100,000. The benefit was mostly for the wealthy then, but in 1988 the bottom bracket increased 3 percent to 15 percent, while the top bracket decreased to 28 percent! The person with $30,000 AGI saw their tax increased from $3,300 to $4,500, while the person with $500,000 AGI saw their tax decreased from $192,500 to $140,000, a saving of $52,500 per year.

The burden for financing the government falls disproportionately on those who can least afford it, while those who reap the most benefit of capitalism are asked to pay proportionally less than their share. If these executives are to receive billions of dollars in compensation, they should take on a larger share of the cost of capitalism. If we went back to the tax rates of the Nixon years, we could fund universal health care and rub out the deficit!

Nicholas G. Schmutte

Avon

Text Only

Opinion

Obama’s Katrina
The politics of it is oily, too

June 8, 2010
From ‘hope’ to ‘nothing improper’
Let’s be grateful that Barack Obama’s contempt for politics as usual is a matter of public record.

June 8, 2010
Letters to the editor
June 8, 2010
Age is simply a matter of mind
I was sitting in a restaurant the other day — I won’t say which one, but I will say it was one of those where you get pancakes as a side dish to anything you order, including salads — when I flipped casually to the menu page for, shall we say, mature guests.

June 8, 2010
Obamacare's disastrous preview
President Barack Obama has an unsettling defense of his health-care reform - it's merely a version of the plan implemented by Massachusetts.

April 12, 2010
Letters to the Editor April 13, 2010
Kudos to Indianapolis Airport Authority for recognizing the need for and creating nursing rooms for breastfeeding and pumping.

April 12, 2010
Give a rat a carrot
It's time once again for "Strange and Disturbing Scientific Studies that are Funded by Government Grants Paid for by Your Tax Dollars."

April 8, 2010
Many unknowns embedded in health reforms
There was isotope coursing through my organs at St. Vincent's Nuclear Heart Center as the health reforms were heading toward President Obama's desk.

April 8, 2010
The great Iran charade
The rules of the great Iranian nuclear charade are simple: We pretend to punish the Iranians for the nuclear-weapons program that they pretend doesn't exist.

April 8, 2010
When fashion advice goes wrong
The weather is warming up nicely. Minds in Indiana are turning toward beaches, barbeques, and fun in the sun.

April 7, 2010
More Opinion Headlines

Opinion

Search Results

Tax burden falls on poor

Has Indianapolis done a good job of hosting the Super Bowl?

Site Map