Submitted photo
This is a photo of a home at 521 North State Road 267 in Avon which the home’s former owner, Robert Chance, pleaded guilty to setting on fire on Jan. 28, 2007.
by Brian Kern
AVON — An Avon man who set his own house ablaze has been sentenced to 10 years in prison after pleading guilty to one count of arson.
Robert Chance, 44, pleaded guilty to the class ‘B’ felony charge and was ordered to pay $101,586.60 in restitution, in addition to the prison term. Investigators believe he burned down his home which had been approaching foreclosure according to investigation reports from the Avon-Washington Township Fire Marshall’s office.
Firefighters were called to Chance’s home at about 10:35 p.m. Jan. 28, 2007, after witnesses saw the blaze and called 911.
Chance was not home at the time of the fire and investigators were unsuccessful in their efforts to reach him until neighbors spotted Chance outside of the home three days later. They called the Fire Marshall’s office who observed that Chance had parked his truck across the street from his home in the Avon-Washington Township Library parking lot.
Chance told investigators that he had been living in the house at the time of the fire and that he had owned the residence since 2004. He also stated that he had recently been laid-off as an aircraft mechanic with ATA. Investigation reports claim that Chance had not made a mortgage payment in over a year and had been going through the foreclosure process.
Upon questioning, Chance told investigators that he had left his house bound for Connersville sometime between 3 p.m. and 3:30 p.m. on the day of the fire. He said that he had intended to visit his father. Chance claimed that he parked his truck outside of his father’s home where he waited all night in anticipation of his father getting up for work at 4:30 a.m. He said that when his father’s bedroom light did not come on, he opted to drive back to Avon.
Chance said that he approached the scene at around 6 a.m. the following day and did see fire equipment in his driveway. However, he drove by the scene without stopping.
Fire investigators also admit that their suspicions were aroused when it was learned that Chance took his pet ferret with him to Connersville, when he had rarely done so in the past.
Investigators were able to determine that the fire had started in the home’s basement and when asked the easiest way to ignite a basement fire, Chance told investigators that there was a box of matches down there and that someone could have used them to light cardboard, magazines, and aerosol cans on fire. He then denied setting the fire himself.
One firefighter suffered a minor knee injury while battling the blaze. He was transported to Hendricks Regional Health in Danville, where he was treated and released.
Hendricks County Prosecutor Patricia Baldwin said that Chance backed off his denial of setting the fire after failing a lie detector test.
“He confessed and apologized to the firefighter he injured after failing the polygraph,” Baldwin said.
She added that the sentence was within the median average for such crimes and that Chance was fortunate that the firefighter’s injuries were not more severe.
brian.kern@flyergroup.com
Local News
Arsonist sentenced to 10 years
Investigators believe man burned down home to avoid foreclosure
- Local News
-
-
County looks to battle water illnesses
The week prior to Memorial Day serves as National Recreational Water Illness Prevention Week.
-
Howie Mandel to serve as 500 honorary announcer
Howie Mandel, standup comedian and judge on “America’s Got Talent,” will serve as honorary announcer for the 96th Indianapolis 500 Mile Race on May 27.
-
Why do young white women risk cancer to be tan?
A CDC report out this month found that nearly one in three white women aged 18 to 25 had used a tanning booth in the previous year. White women aged 18 to 21 went the most often, averaging 27.6 sessions per year—that’s over two sessions per month—while nearly 70 percent said they had gone at least 10 times in the last year.
-
BCSC raises $30,000 for Race for the Cure
Basketball season may have ended a few months ago for the Bulldog community, but the school system decided to give the Susan G. Komen Foundation one extra large, record assist as they recently announced raising $30,000 in the Race for the Cure fight against breast cancer.
-
Drive for Damon golf scramble set
A golf scramble to raise money for disabled former Ben Davis High School basketball star Damon Parks is set for 1 p.m. June 3 at Riverside Golf Course in Indianapolis.
-
Brownsburg fights back with Relay for Life
For 24 hours, it will be non-stop community versus cancer in town as the Relay for Life event will takes place. The event will start at 5 p.m. June 1 at the Brownsburg West Middle School track.
-
Dawes, county celebrate retirement
The impact that Dennis Dawes has left on Hendricks Regional Health will not be soon forgotten.
-
Young racing team plants roots and more in Brownsburg
When Belardi Racing decided to uproot its operation and move to Hendricks County, they got the idea that maybe they should put some roots down.
-
500 Festival celebrates with breakfast event
With practices and qualifications going on at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, Saturday was a busy day for everyone involved.
-
Relay returns
With battling cancer and raising awareness in mind, the Wayne Township area hosted its Relay for Life this past weekend at the Chapel Hill 7th and 8th Grade Center.
- More Local News Headlines
-
County looks to battle water illnesses

